|
Cholesterol is a vital substance in our bodies. It is the building for all sex hormones and vitamin D. The widely advertised concept that “the lower your cholesterol the better off you are” is flawed. Cholesterol needs to be corrected to normal levels and sometimes below normal levels in those at high risk for cholesterol related illness.
On the other hand those form a long line of people who die of sudden death, heart attacks or strokes are at high risk for developing cholesterol related disease even with normal or borderline cholesterol levels. Furthermore, those with elevated inflammatory markers, diabetes, obesity, hypertension, tobacco, emotional stress use or autoimmune disease are at higher risk for developing cholesterol related disease and need more aggressive treatment. All such individuals require additional testing to discover risks not revealed on a routine cholesterol panel.
Furthermore, the concept that all hyperlipidemia is high cholesterol is also flawed. Treatment of hyperlipidemia in the 21st century goes far beyond looking at a simple cholesterol panel and reducing cholesterol to below 200.
LPP Testing
For assessing additional risk factors for cardiovascular disease we routinely use LPP panel assessment offered through Spectracell Laboratory in Texas. This panel is by far the most comprehensive testing available for assessing additional risks for developing cholesterol related disease at any level of total cholesterol. Additional factors ascertained through LPP testing include:
C-reactive protein (CRP): protein that is formed in blood in response to inflammation. Levels of this protein are important risk factor for cardiovascular disease but disproportionately so in women. Levels of CRP are often elevated in inflammatory conditions such as autoimmune disease but it is important to recognize that autoimmune disease is an independent risk factor for developing cardiovascular disease.
Lipoprotein (a) (Lp(a)): Lp(a) is a protein on the LDL (bad cholesterol) that significantly increases the propensity of the LDL to deposit and lead to formation of cholesterol plaques in arteries. This is a genetic factor that can not be modified by either exercise or diet. High levels of Lp(a) can only be modified by niacin and to a lesser extent by medications like Tricor or Trilipix. Very high levels of Lp(a) may not be normalized despite high doses of the above medications. The only solution for such individuals can only be negated by lowering LDL levels below 70, which often involves the use of statins.
Homocysteine: Homocysteine is a by product of inappropriate metabolism of folic acid. Accumulation of this substance is hypothesized to lead to a higher tendency of LDL deposition at any level of LDL. It is important to recognize that therapy with niacin although very beneficial for the most part can lead to a rise in Homocysteine. High Homocysteine levels can be treated in some individuals by using folic acid. In many, inappropriate metabolism of folic acid can not be overcome by folic acid alone due to a genetic deficiency in the enzyme responsible for activating folic acid to the methylated form. A newer product, methylated folic acid marketed under the brand name Deplin, is touted as an effective treatment. It is also found to be useful as an adjunct therapy for depression. Experience is limited with this new product and more data is required to verify its effectiveness but in lieu of other alternatives we recommend use of this product for those at high risk. Recent large scale studies have identified Homocysteine as a marker for those with metabolic dysfunction and cardiac risk however have not demonstrated definite benefit in correcting Homocysteine to normal levels. As a result we reserve therapy for this problem or those at highest risk only.
Buoyancy: Another reason why the simple testing of lipid panels is not fully effective is that a large buoyant LDL is unlikely to deposit in arteries whereas a small dense LDL is likely to deposit at any given absolute level. At the same time not all HDL cholesterol is protective against cholesterol deposition. Testing the buoyancy of HDL can safeguard against misinterpreting a high HDL level as necessarily protective against cardiovascular disease.
Apo-lipoprotein A (good) and Apo-lipoprotein B (bad): These markers are questionably useful in further assessing cardiovascular risk in those with abnormal lipid profiles. Another marker, Apo-lipoprotein C, has shown great promise as a single indicator outside of a traditional cholesterol panel to supersede all other marker in predicting cardiovascular risk. Unfortunately, to the best of my knowledge, this marker is still only available in the research setting and is not available to the public at large.
Other tests that can be useful in assessing include:
Hemoglobin A1C (Hgb A1C or glycated hemoglobin): This test reveals a 3 month average of blood sugar. Elevated levels of Hgb A1C are now accepted as a diagnostic criteria for diabetes and it is also widely accepted that even at borderline levels many perdiabetics begin to accumulate the complications of diabetes including cardiovascular disease.
Glycomark: This test reveals a 6 week average of post-prandial blood sugars. Most pre-diabetics will have low glycomark levels, correlating with high blood sugars after a meal. Many diabetics will remain at high risk for cardiovascular disease despite having relatively normal Hgb A1C. These individuals benefit from specific therapies aimed at lowering post-prandial blood sugars.
C-peptide: This refers to the level of naturally produced insulin. Most pre-diabetics will have elevated fasting C-peptide levels while fasting. By definition, they all have higher than normal C-peptide secretion in response to a standard intake of carbohydrates. To our knowledge, we are the only place where you can assess serial C-peptide levels in response to a carbohydrate challenge. Blood sugar response to a standard carbohydrate challenge was long considered the standard for diagnosing diabetes. However, the value of finding out the cat is already out of the bag as opposed to diagnosing the problem before it gets too far is questionable. Early diagnosis of pre-diabetes is valuable because once the pancreas is burned out return to normal becomes much more difficult. Lifestyle and pharmaceutical interventions can prevent the development of diabetes in such individuals thus greatly reducing risk.
Thyroid Function Testing: Hypothyroidism (low thyroid) is a common cause of metabolic derangements leading to multiple issues including abnormal cholesterol panels. The abnormalities can range form pure elevated cholesterol to those typically seen in metabolic syndrome including high triglycerides and low HDL. In many such patients as long as the cholesterol abnormalities are not severe the treatment of high cholesterol can be delayed until thyroid abnormalities have been appropriately treated. Guidelines for the assessment and therapy of hypothyroidism are summarized elsewhere on this website.
Testosterone: Andropause, the lowering of free testosterone levels in aging men is extremely common after the 6th decade of life. It is associated with multiple symptoms and signs which can lead to abnormal cholesterol metabolism. Similar to the therapy of cholesterol in hypothyroidism, in men with abnormal testosterone levels and mild to moderate cholesterol abnormalities treatment for cholesterol can be safely delayed until testosterone levels are normalized. Guidelines for the assessment and therapy of hypothyroidism are summarized elsewhere on this website.
Carotid Ultrasound: The carotid artery is the most accessible major artery for direct visualization. Deposits in this artery and the thickness of the arterial wall correlate well with deposits of cholesterol elsewhere in the body. Furthermore, large deposits of cholesterol are an independent risk for developing strokes. Besides the size of these plaques the actual shape and architecture of these plaques can be visualized. Actual presence of ulcers within these plaques and presence of loose pieces of plaque are extremely concerning and constitute ground for immediate surgical intervention.
CT Calcium Score: This is frequently employed as a means for screening for cholesterol deposits in the arteries of the heart. If a score of zero is obtained then we can rest assured that there is no coronary disease. However, the majority of these tests reveal intermediate results. Thus we are obligated to proceed with cardiac stress testing in many individuals who do not otherwise require such testing. As a result, we do not utilize this modality frequently. This test coronary disease.
Cardiac Stress Testing: Standardized protocols for gradually raising heart rate to maximum predicted levels based on age are widely accepted as a means for assessing the presence of flow limiting coronary disease. Traditional testing using electrocardiographic (EKG) monitoring are sufficient for most patients. The accuracy of these tests can be improved by combining them with echocardiography. For still equivocal results from both above tests nuclear stress tests can be utilized. For those unable to exercise on a treadmill medications can be used to speed up the heart to target levels. We prefer to proceed with stress testing over screening with CT calcium scoring as they provide information regarding functionally significant disease rather than detecting calcium that even in large amounts deposited in the arteries may never produce flow limiting lesions in the arteries.
Emotional Stress: It is vital to recognize the role of stress in the development of cholesterol related disease. Cholesterol levels can rise quickly in response to emotional stress. Furthermore, the spasm in the arteries, common in high stress situations, with any level of cholesterol deposit can lead to heart attacks and strokes. Appropriate counseling and use of medications to help with stress management can be as effective if not more effective than cholesterol lowering medications at managing such stress related diseases. We recommend laughter yoga as a healthy means of increasing laughter in your life and adjusting your perception of the stressors in your life.
Who needs Treatment for Elevated Cholesterol
We always begin this process by assessing the individual and their risk factors for cholesterol related disease. To begin with if a patient comes from a family where everyone lives to be over 80 and no one dies of a stroke or heart attack then this single factor supersedes much of anything you see on a cholesterol test. These individuals are likely suffering from the coveted disease called “longevity syndrome”. They won’t die of cholesterol related disease but may suffer from side effects of cholesterol medications while not deriving any benefit from such therapy. The typical cholesterol panel of a person with longevity syndrome is as follows
Example 1
Total Cholesterol 280
LDL (bad cholesterol) 140
HDL (good cholesterol) >100
Triglycerides (fats) 82
Although the idea of not treating someone with a cholesterol of 280 is foreign to most physicians this is the typical profile of someone who will never die of cholesterol related disease. To insure the safety of our patients we routinely recommend further testing for such individuals by further testing other risk factors in cholesterol panel included in an LPP panel.
In general, those with very high HDL levels have elevated levels of enzymes that make HDL. This is sometimes accompanied by mild elevations of liver enzymes detected in routine blood analyses of liver enzymes. These individuals sometimes undergo unnecessary work up for abnormal liver enzymes. We routinely rule out the presence of hepatitis but further work up with liver biopsies are usually not indicated.
Another group of people with similar cholesterol panels are those who over absorb cholesterol. Although most such individuals truly do not treatment medications such as Zetia are effective in reducing the absorption of cholesterol. Treatment with other medications is unnecessary.
Example 2
A patient with metabolic syndrome (combination of obesity, hypertension and high cholesterol) typically has the following cholesterol panel:
Total Cholesterol 240
LDL (bad cholesterol) 180
HDL (good cholesterol) 25
Triglycerides (fats) 282
Although none of the findings on this cholesterol panel are all concerning, the low cholesterol and high triglycerides are even more problematic than the high total cholesterol and LDL. This individual needs further testing for diabetes and pre-diabetes. The treatment of this patient should focus more on weight loss, reduction of carbohydrate intake and use of supplements and medications aimed at increasing insulin sensitivity. Furthermore, LPP testing for assessing additional risk factors and 2 hour glucose and C peptide testing may be helpful to assess the extent of insulin resistance.
Example 3
Total Cholesterol 290
LDL (bad cholesterol) 210
HDL (good cholesterol) 35
Triglycerides (fats) 182
This patient suffers from a pure high cholesterol condition. Although the triglyceride and HDL are still not very favorable the main issue is related to the LDL and total cholesterol levels. This is a typical cholesterol panel of someone with both a genetic propensity towards this problem as well as a diet likely high in meats, cheese and things that include the word “cream”. Simple reduction in intake of these substances may improve the panel. However, it is important to recognize that even with the most strict of diets this panel can only be improved by 25%. This person needs therapy with a statin medicaiton (lipitor, crestor, simvastatin, ...). LPP testing can identify other risk factors and help define the appropriate target levels for cholesterol therapy in such patients.
Example 4
Total Cholesterol 190
LDL (bad cholesterol) 150
HDL (good cholesterol) 15
Triglycerides (fats) 600
This panel reveals a patient with metabolic syndrome who is at high risk for developing pancreatitis. Triglycerides at concentrations above 500 are a clear risk factor developing pancreatitis. Additionally, those with this high of triglyceride level will have a change in the color of their blood: Blood appears white. Treatment is often with medications like Lovaza (highly concentrated fish oil), Tricor/Trilipix, niacin, resins. See pro’s and con’s of medical therapy for abnormal lipids.
|